• About Us
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Contact Us
Sunday, October 26, 2025
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
Time Line News
  • Home
  • Latest News
  • Pakistan
  • World
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
    What dangerous disease is Kim Kardashian suffering from? Model reveals

    What dangerous disease is Kim Kardashian suffering from? Model reveals

    Nargis meets Maulana Tariq Jameel in Mecca;

    Nargis meets Maulana Tariq Jameel in Mecca;

    Famous Bollywood actress admitted to hospital.

    Famous Bollywood actress admitted to hospital.

    Fiza Ali’s new song “Mehndi Wali Raat” ready for release.

    Fiza Ali’s new song “Mehndi Wali Raat” ready for release.

    Famous TikToker Rumisa Saeed passes away after traffic accident .

    Famous TikToker Rumisa Saeed passes away after traffic accident .

    Bigg Boss contestant Tanya Mittal’s big scandal has come to light

    Bigg Boss contestant Tanya Mittal’s big scandal has come to light

    Hania Amir at awards ceremony; Video goes viral.

    Hania Amir at awards ceremony; Video goes viral.

    Hania Amir admitted to hospital again; fans worried

    Hania Amir admitted to hospital again; fans worried

    Fraud case worth crores of rupees; Actress Shilpa Shetty under tight security.

    Fraud case worth crores of rupees; Actress Shilpa Shetty under tight security.

  • Technology
    Saudi tech group launches AI hub in Pakistan for research, digital solutions.

    Saudi tech group launches AI hub in Pakistan for research, digital solutions.

    Pakistan Showcases Digital Transformation at GITEX Global 2025, Reports 20% Annual Growth in IT Exports

    Pakistan Showcases Digital Transformation at GITEX Global 2025, Reports 20% Annual Growth in IT Exports

    Say It, Edit It – AI Edit Genie Rules Your Gallery with the realme 15 Series Party Revolution

    Say It, Edit It – AI Edit Genie Rules Your Gallery with the realme 15 Series Party Revolution

    Spotify Now in ChatGPT, Turning Your Prompts into Personalized Picks

    Spotify Now in ChatGPT, Turning Your Prompts into Personalized Picks

    OPPO INAUGURATES PESHAWAR FLAGSHIP STORE, ANNOUNCING THE NATIONWIDE AVAILABILITY OF OPPO A6 PRO FROM 4TH OCTOBER.

    OPPO INAUGURATES PESHAWAR FLAGSHIP STORE, ANNOUNCING THE NATIONWIDE AVAILABILITY OF OPPO A6 PRO FROM 4TH OCTOBER.

    Chatgpt becomes a global facilitator for plagiarists

    Now ChatGPT will work even when users sleepOpen AI is going to introduce a new feature for ChatGPT

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Health
  • Editorial
    • Blog
    • Opinion
  • E-Paper
  • Home
  • Latest News
  • Pakistan
  • World
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
    What dangerous disease is Kim Kardashian suffering from? Model reveals

    What dangerous disease is Kim Kardashian suffering from? Model reveals

    Nargis meets Maulana Tariq Jameel in Mecca;

    Nargis meets Maulana Tariq Jameel in Mecca;

    Famous Bollywood actress admitted to hospital.

    Famous Bollywood actress admitted to hospital.

    Fiza Ali’s new song “Mehndi Wali Raat” ready for release.

    Fiza Ali’s new song “Mehndi Wali Raat” ready for release.

    Famous TikToker Rumisa Saeed passes away after traffic accident .

    Famous TikToker Rumisa Saeed passes away after traffic accident .

    Bigg Boss contestant Tanya Mittal’s big scandal has come to light

    Bigg Boss contestant Tanya Mittal’s big scandal has come to light

    Hania Amir at awards ceremony; Video goes viral.

    Hania Amir at awards ceremony; Video goes viral.

    Hania Amir admitted to hospital again; fans worried

    Hania Amir admitted to hospital again; fans worried

    Fraud case worth crores of rupees; Actress Shilpa Shetty under tight security.

    Fraud case worth crores of rupees; Actress Shilpa Shetty under tight security.

  • Technology
    Saudi tech group launches AI hub in Pakistan for research, digital solutions.

    Saudi tech group launches AI hub in Pakistan for research, digital solutions.

    Pakistan Showcases Digital Transformation at GITEX Global 2025, Reports 20% Annual Growth in IT Exports

    Pakistan Showcases Digital Transformation at GITEX Global 2025, Reports 20% Annual Growth in IT Exports

    Say It, Edit It – AI Edit Genie Rules Your Gallery with the realme 15 Series Party Revolution

    Say It, Edit It – AI Edit Genie Rules Your Gallery with the realme 15 Series Party Revolution

    Spotify Now in ChatGPT, Turning Your Prompts into Personalized Picks

    Spotify Now in ChatGPT, Turning Your Prompts into Personalized Picks

    OPPO INAUGURATES PESHAWAR FLAGSHIP STORE, ANNOUNCING THE NATIONWIDE AVAILABILITY OF OPPO A6 PRO FROM 4TH OCTOBER.

    OPPO INAUGURATES PESHAWAR FLAGSHIP STORE, ANNOUNCING THE NATIONWIDE AVAILABILITY OF OPPO A6 PRO FROM 4TH OCTOBER.

    Chatgpt becomes a global facilitator for plagiarists

    Now ChatGPT will work even when users sleepOpen AI is going to introduce a new feature for ChatGPT

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Health
  • Editorial
    • Blog
    • Opinion
  • E-Paper
No Result
View All Result
Time Line News
No Result
View All Result
Home Business

Monsoon Disasters and the Urgent Need for Reforms in Pakistan’s NFC Award

by Web Desk
September 1, 2025
in Business
Monsoon Disasters and the Urgent Need for Reforms in Pakistan’s NFC Award
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Islamabad: The recurring devastation caused by monsoon rains in Pakistan has once again highlighted the structural weaknesses in governance, financial planning, and resource distribution. Cities such as Karachi, Lahore, Peshawar, and Quetta experience flooding, collapsed infrastructure, and urban paralysis every rainy season. Despite repeated promises of reform and billions allocated through federal and provincial budgets, the situation continues to deteriorate.

This crisis is increasingly linked to questions about the National Finance Commission (NFC) Award, a constitutional mechanism designed to ensure fair distribution of financial resources between the federation and the provinces. Critics argue that while the NFC Award was intended to strengthen service delivery and promote balanced development, it has, in practice, failed to address Pakistan’s long-term challenges—particularly those related to urban governance, disaster preparedness, and human development.


Understanding the NFC Award and Its Constitutional Role

The NFC Award is provided under Article 160 of the Constitution of Pakistan, which mandates a periodic formula for revenue sharing between the federal government and the provinces. The objective is twofold:

  1. Equitable Distribution: Ensure that all provinces receive their fair share of national resources.
  2. Enhanced Service Delivery: Enable provincial governments to provide healthcare, education, clean water, housing, infrastructure, and disaster management services at the local level.

Under the Seventh NFC Award of 2010, provinces saw their share of divisible pool resources rise significantly—from 47.5% to 57.5%. This was hailed at the time as a historic step toward provincial autonomy, especially after the 18th Constitutional Amendment, which devolved several critical sectors—including health, education, and social welfare—to the provinces.

However, more than a decade later, the practical results remain disappointing.


The Problem: Why Provinces Are Failing Despite Greater Resources

1. Development Budgets vs. Non-Development Expenses

One of the key criticisms is that provinces underspend on development projects—such as infrastructure upgrades, education reforms, and healthcare improvements—while overspending on non-developmental expenses, primarily salaries, perks, and pensions for government employees.

This imbalance has created a situation where long-term investments in human development and urban resilience are neglected, leaving cities vulnerable to disasters like monsoon flooding.

2. Political Prioritization Over Public Needs

Instead of investing in long-term projects such as drainage systems, water supply networks, or public transport, provincial governments often focus on short-term, politically popular schemes like flyovers, beautification campaigns, or subsidies. These may bring immediate visibility but do little to solve structural problems.

3. Weak Local Governments

Despite gaining more autonomy after the 18th Amendment, provinces have been reluctant to empower local governments. Instead, power has been centralized at the provincial capitals, depriving municipalities and districts of the ability to effectively respond to local crises.

This lack of grassroots governance has left cities like Karachi in particular at the mercy of bureaucratic delays and overlapping authorities, leading to chaos every monsoon season.


The Federal Government’s Dilemma

While provinces have gained a larger share of resources, the federal government continues to shoulder massive responsibilities:

  • Debt repayment on domestic and international loans.
  • Defense expenditures, which remain a large component of the national budget.
  • Energy subsidies to keep electricity and fuel affordable.
  • Large-scale infrastructure projects, such as motorways, dams, and power plants.

With reduced financial space, the federal government often struggles to meet its obligations, while provinces fail to mobilize their own revenues. Experts note that tax collection in provinces remains dismal, as provincial administrations rely almost entirely on transfers from Islamabad rather than creating sustainable revenue systems.


The Formula Debate: Is Resource Distribution Fair?

The current NFC formula is based primarily on population size (82% weight), with other factors such as poverty, backwardness, and revenue generation capacity receiving far less weight.

  • Provinces like Punjab, being the most populous, receive the lion’s share.
  • Smaller provinces—particularly Balochistan—argue that this formula is unfair, as it ignores their low population density, geographical size, and higher levels of poverty and underdevelopment.
  • Even within provinces, intra-provincial inequities are glaring: rural areas remain deprived while metropolitan centers consume most resources.

This imbalance has long been a source of political tension, fueling grievances in smaller provinces that already feel marginalized in Pakistan’s power structure.


Karachi: The Most Striking Example of NFC’s Contradictions

Karachi, Pakistan’s financial capital and largest city, illustrates the paradox of the NFC Award.

  • The city contributes the largest share of Pakistan’s tax revenues, including customs duties, corporate taxes, and indirect taxes.
  • Yet, after every monsoon season, Karachi is left flooded, dysfunctional, and neglected, with open drains, crumbling roads, and overflowing garbage heaps.
  • The city’s governance structure is fragmented among provincial authorities, municipal corporations, cantonment boards, and federal agencies, resulting in poor coordination.

This raises a pressing question: If the city that contributes the most is consistently the most neglected, is the NFC Award truly serving its purpose?


Expert Opinions: The Need for NFC Reforms

Economists and policy experts agree that reforms in the NFC Award are urgently needed. However, they caution that reforms should not mean rolling back provincial autonomy. Instead, the focus must be on efficiency, transparency, and accountability.

Proposed Reforms Include:

  1. Performance-Based Allocations: Provinces that show improvements in education, health, tax collection, and disaster preparedness should receive additional incentives.
  2. Independent Monitoring Mechanisms: Establishing an autonomous body to audit resource utilization, ensuring funds are not wasted on politically motivated projects.
  3. Strengthening Local Governments: Devolving more power and resources to the municipal and district levels, where service delivery directly impacts citizens.
  4. Balanced Distribution Formula: Giving greater weight to poverty, underdevelopment, and revenue generation capacity, rather than relying almost entirely on population.
  5. Clear Federal-Provincial Division: Clarifying responsibilities to prevent duplication, overlap, and wastage of resources.

Monsoon Disasters as a Wake-Up Call

Every year, the monsoon season exposes Pakistan’s weak governance and resource mismanagement. Flooding not only damages homes and roads but also leads to loss of lives, economic paralysis, outbreaks of waterborne diseases, and displacement of vulnerable communities.

The irony is that despite repeated disasters, little progress has been made in urban resilience planning. Drainage systems remain outdated, disaster management authorities lack funding, and coordination among agencies is minimal.

For critics, this is the clearest proof that the NFC Award in its current form has failed to meet its constitutional objective of strengthening service delivery at the grassroots level.


The Way Forward: Turning the NFC Award Into a Solution

The NFC Award, if properly reformed, can be a powerful tool for equitable growth. Instead of being seen as a burden on the federation, it should become a framework for shared responsibility.

  • Provinces must take ownership of their responsibilities, increasing their own tax bases and ensuring that funds are used for development and disaster preparedness.
  • The federal government must maintain fiscal discipline while ensuring that smaller provinces are not left behind.
  • Local governments must be empowered and funded to manage essential services like sanitation, drainage, and emergency response.

Ultimately, unless accountability, transparency, and fairness are built into the system, the NFC Award risks becoming not a solution but a symbol of Pakistan’s financial dysfunction.


Conclusion

The devastation brought by monsoon rains every year is not just a natural disaster—it is a reflection of systemic governance failures and poor financial management. The NFC Award, despite its noble objectives, has not translated into improved service delivery, particularly in cities like Karachi that contribute the most but suffer the worst.

Reforming the NFC Award does not mean weakening provincial autonomy; rather, it means creating a performance-driven, transparent, and equitable system where resources are used effectively for the welfare of citizens.

Unless Pakistan embraces these reforms, the NFC Award will remain a symbol of inefficiency and inequality, while ordinary citizens continue to pay the price with their lives and livelihoods every monsoon season.

Read more:….

Tags: commissiongovernmentinternationalNationalsocial mediatime line news
Web Desk

Web Desk

Related Posts

UK Lifts Ban on Pakistani Airlines: A New Era in Aviation and Bilateral Relations

PM felicitates nation, diaspora for PIA’s direct flights to Manchester.

by Web Desk
October 25, 2025
0

ISLAMABAD, Oct 25 (APP):Prime Minister Muhammad Shehbaz Sharif, Saturday, felicitated the entire nation, especially those Pakistanis residing in the United...

Recovery in Economic Confidence among Global Accountants’ stalls in Q3.

Recovery in Economic Confidence among Global Accountants’ stalls in Q3.

by Web Desk
October 24, 2025
0

Lahore, October 24, 2025:* The ACCA and IMA Global Economic Conditions Survey (GECS) revealed that confidence among global accountants declined...

HBL Zarai Services Limited Expands Footprint into Sindh with Launch in Mirpur Mathelo

HBL Zarai Services Limited Expands Footprint into Sindh with Launch in Mirpur Mathelo

by Web Desk
October 24, 2025
0

Dad Leghari, Mirpur Mathelo October 24, 2025: HBL Zarai Services Limited has officially launched its services in Sindh, marking a...

Managing Director & CEO BoK Inaugurates Bank of Khyber Auditorium at Khpal Kor Foundation, Swat

Managing Director & CEO BoK Inaugurates Bank of Khyber Auditorium at Khpal Kor Foundation, Swat

by Web Desk
October 24, 2025
0

Bank of Khyber (BoK) has reaffirmed its commitment to community development and social responsibility with the inauguration of the Bank...

Gold becomes cheaper; Prices decrease at global and local levels

Gold becomes cheaper; Prices decrease at global and local levels

by Web Desk
October 24, 2025
0

The price of gold had decreased in international and local markets yesterday as well. Karachi:Gold became cheaper due to further...

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

Sushmita Sen born in February 2023? Fans are surprised

Sushmita Sen born in February 2023? Fans are surprised

1 year ago
FIFA suspends Pakistan Football Federation’s membership

FIFA suspends Pakistan Football Federation’s membership

9 months ago

Category

  • Home
  • Top Stories
  • Latest News
  • Pakistan
  • World
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Technology
  • Health
  • Lifestyle
  • Editorial
  • Blog
  • Opinion
  • E-Paper

Social Media

Facebook Instagram Twitter LinkedIn

About us

“Time Line News” is where knowledge meets enlightenment.

With a commitment to providing accurate, fair updates, we aim to be your go-to source for information on local and global events.

  • About Us
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Contact Us

Time Line News © 2024. All Rights Reserved. Website Designed & Developed by AK Web Solutions

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Top Stories
  • Latest News
  • Pakistan
  • World
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Technology
  • Health
  • Lifestyle
  • Editorial
  • Blog
  • Opinion
  • E-Paper

Time Line News © 2024. All Rights Reserved. Website Designed & Developed by AK Web Solutions

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In