• About Us
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Contact Us
Friday, July 18, 2025
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
Time Line News
  • Home
  • Latest News
  • Pakistan
  • World
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
    Sara Khan's New Look Sparks Cosmetic Surgery Rumors: Fans Question Sudden Transformation

    Sara Khan’s New Look Sparks Cosmetic Surgery Rumors: Fans Question Sudden Transformation

    Natural Death or Foul Play? Forensic Report Reveals Truth Behind Humaira Asghar’s Mysterious Death

    Natural Death or Foul Play? Forensic Report Reveals Truth Behind Humaira Asghar’s Mysterious Death

    Meera Appeals to British Government for UK Visa to Visit Terminally Ill Sister

    Meera Appeals to British Government for UK Visa to Visit Terminally Ill Sister

    Hira Mani's Bridal Dance Video Goes Viral: A Blend of Nostalgia, Poetry, and Glamour

    Hira Mani’s Bridal Dance Video Goes Viral: A Blend of Nostalgia, Poetry, and Glamour

    Korean Actress Kang Seo-ha Passes Away at 31 After Battle with Stomach Cancer

    Korean Actress Kang Seo-ha Passes Away at 31 After Battle with Stomach Cancer

    New Revelations Emerge in Investigation of Actress Humaira Asghar’s Death

    New Revelations Emerge in Investigation of Actress Humaira Asghar’s Death

    DIG South Reveals Shocking Details About Humaira Asghar’s Death: Mystery Deepens as Post-Mortem Report Points to Months-Old Demise

    DIG South Reveals Shocking Details About Humaira Asghar’s Death: Mystery Deepens as Post-Mortem Report Points to Months-Old Demise

    After Saif Ali Khan, Kareena Kapoor Also Targeted in Scary Incident: Security Head Ronit Roy Reveals Details

    After Saif Ali Khan, Kareena Kapoor Also Targeted in Scary Incident: Security Head Ronit Roy Reveals Details

    Major Breakthrough in Humaira Asghar Death Case: Critical Data Retrieved from Actress’s Devices Fuels Investigation

    Major Breakthrough in Humaira Asghar Death Case: Critical Data Retrieved from Actress’s Devices Fuels Investigation

  • Technology
    Microsoft Strikes Landmark Deal to Reduce Carbon Emissions with Underground Waste Storage

    Microsoft Strikes Landmark Deal to Reduce Carbon Emissions with Underground Waste Storage

    Facebook Cracks Down on Pirated Content to Protect Original Creators and Improve User Experience

    Facebook Cracks Down on Pirated Content to Protect Original Creators and Improve User Experience

    NASA Releases Closest-Ever Image of the Sun Captured by Parker Solar Probe

    NASA Releases Closest-Ever Image of the Sun Captured by Parker Solar Probe

    Samsung Dominates Smartphone Popularity Charts with New Releases: Galaxy Z Fold 7 and Z Flip 7 Lead the Pack

    Samsung Dominates Smartphone Popularity Charts with New Releases: Galaxy Z Fold 7 and Z Flip 7 Lead the Pack

    A Meteorite Older Than Our Solar System: The Discovery of 3I ATLAS and Its Galactic Origins

    A Meteorite Older Than Our Solar System: The Discovery of 3I ATLAS and Its Galactic Origins

    China Develops World's Lightest Mind-Control Device for Bees

    China Develops World’s Lightest Mind-Control Device for Bees

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Health
  • Editorial
    • Blog
    • Opinion
  • E-Paper
  • Home
  • Latest News
  • Pakistan
  • World
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
    Sara Khan's New Look Sparks Cosmetic Surgery Rumors: Fans Question Sudden Transformation

    Sara Khan’s New Look Sparks Cosmetic Surgery Rumors: Fans Question Sudden Transformation

    Natural Death or Foul Play? Forensic Report Reveals Truth Behind Humaira Asghar’s Mysterious Death

    Natural Death or Foul Play? Forensic Report Reveals Truth Behind Humaira Asghar’s Mysterious Death

    Meera Appeals to British Government for UK Visa to Visit Terminally Ill Sister

    Meera Appeals to British Government for UK Visa to Visit Terminally Ill Sister

    Hira Mani's Bridal Dance Video Goes Viral: A Blend of Nostalgia, Poetry, and Glamour

    Hira Mani’s Bridal Dance Video Goes Viral: A Blend of Nostalgia, Poetry, and Glamour

    Korean Actress Kang Seo-ha Passes Away at 31 After Battle with Stomach Cancer

    Korean Actress Kang Seo-ha Passes Away at 31 After Battle with Stomach Cancer

    New Revelations Emerge in Investigation of Actress Humaira Asghar’s Death

    New Revelations Emerge in Investigation of Actress Humaira Asghar’s Death

    DIG South Reveals Shocking Details About Humaira Asghar’s Death: Mystery Deepens as Post-Mortem Report Points to Months-Old Demise

    DIG South Reveals Shocking Details About Humaira Asghar’s Death: Mystery Deepens as Post-Mortem Report Points to Months-Old Demise

    After Saif Ali Khan, Kareena Kapoor Also Targeted in Scary Incident: Security Head Ronit Roy Reveals Details

    After Saif Ali Khan, Kareena Kapoor Also Targeted in Scary Incident: Security Head Ronit Roy Reveals Details

    Major Breakthrough in Humaira Asghar Death Case: Critical Data Retrieved from Actress’s Devices Fuels Investigation

    Major Breakthrough in Humaira Asghar Death Case: Critical Data Retrieved from Actress’s Devices Fuels Investigation

  • Technology
    Microsoft Strikes Landmark Deal to Reduce Carbon Emissions with Underground Waste Storage

    Microsoft Strikes Landmark Deal to Reduce Carbon Emissions with Underground Waste Storage

    Facebook Cracks Down on Pirated Content to Protect Original Creators and Improve User Experience

    Facebook Cracks Down on Pirated Content to Protect Original Creators and Improve User Experience

    NASA Releases Closest-Ever Image of the Sun Captured by Parker Solar Probe

    NASA Releases Closest-Ever Image of the Sun Captured by Parker Solar Probe

    Samsung Dominates Smartphone Popularity Charts with New Releases: Galaxy Z Fold 7 and Z Flip 7 Lead the Pack

    Samsung Dominates Smartphone Popularity Charts with New Releases: Galaxy Z Fold 7 and Z Flip 7 Lead the Pack

    A Meteorite Older Than Our Solar System: The Discovery of 3I ATLAS and Its Galactic Origins

    A Meteorite Older Than Our Solar System: The Discovery of 3I ATLAS and Its Galactic Origins

    China Develops World's Lightest Mind-Control Device for Bees

    China Develops World’s Lightest Mind-Control Device for Bees

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Health
  • Editorial
    • Blog
    • Opinion
  • E-Paper
No Result
View All Result
Time Line News
No Result
View All Result
Home Latest News

Justice Gul Hassan Considered for Interim and Permanent Chief Justice Role: Judicial Commission Faces Complex Legal Debate

by Web Desk
July 2, 2025
in Latest News, Pakistan
Justice Gul Hassan Considered for Interim and Permanent Chief Justice Role: Judicial Commission Faces Complex Legal Debate
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Islamabad – The process to appoint the new Chief Justice of the Islamabad High Court (IHC) has taken a dramatic turn as the Judicial Commission of Pakistan (JCP) considered both interim and permanent appointment options for Justice Mian Gul Hassan Aurangzeb. The debate has raised significant legal, constitutional, and political questions regarding judicial seniority, intra-court appeals, and the independence of the judiciary.

Sources close to the Judicial Commission confirmed that Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) Yahya Afridi floated the idea of appointing Justice Mian Gul Hassan Aurangzeb as an interim Chief Justice of the Islamabad High Court until the matter of seniority among the IHC judges is conclusively resolved through an intra-court appeal.

This case is particularly significant, as it marks one of the rare instances in Pakistan’s judicial history where appointments of permanent Chief Justices in four High Courts were considered in a single session. While appointments to the other three high courts were made swiftly, the Islamabad High Court’s case stood out due to complex internal disagreements and pending legal challenges.


Background: Tensions Over Seniority and Judicial Appointments

At the core of the issue is the seniority dispute among judges of the Islamabad High Court, which has become the subject of an intra-court appeal filed by five judges of the IHC. This appeal challenges the determination of seniority made by the President of Pakistan, which allegedly bypassed constitutional consultation protocols.

As a result of this legal grey area, appointing a permanent Chief Justice has become a politically sensitive and legally complicated decision. The JCP, comprising both judicial and non-judicial members, is divided over whether the appointment should be made now or deferred until the court adjudicates the matter of seniority.


Chief Justice’s Proposal for Interim Appointment

According to well-placed sources, CJP Yahya Afridi recommended that Justice Mian Gul Hassan be appointed as interim Chief Justice until the intra-court appeal is heard and resolved. The rationale was to ensure that judicial functioning and administrative control in the IHC remain intact while avoiding the potential fallout of confirming a controversial permanent appointment.

This suggestion received the support of two PTI-nominated members of the Judicial Commission—Senator Ali Zafar and Barrister Gohar Ali Khan—along with Zulfiqar Abbasi, a representative from the Islamabad Bar Council. However, Justice Muneeb Akhtar, a sitting judge of the Supreme Court, opposed this proposal, leading to further fragmentation within the commission.


The Case for Permanent Appointment: A Bid for Stability?

While some members favored an interim solution, other members believed that appointing Justice Mian Gul Hassan as the permanent Chief Justice could bring administrative stability to the IHC. Proponents of this view argued that key judicial functions and electoral processes are currently tied to the leadership within the Islamabad High Court, and the ongoing uncertainty hampers both.

One legal analyst noted, “With general elections looming and legal challenges increasing, having a strong, permanent Chief Justice at the IHC could prove critical in ensuring the court’s role as a constitutional watchdog.”


Justice Mansoor Ali Shah’s Opposition and Constitutional Concerns

Adding another layer of complexity, Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah—currently a judge of the Supreme Court—expressed his opposition in writing. In a letter submitted to the Commission Secretary a day before the meeting, Justice Shah emphasized that any move to appoint a permanent Chief Justice should be suspended until the seniority appeal is decided.

He raised serious legal questions about the role of the President in determining seniority. Justice Shah argued that Article 200 of the Constitution—which governs the transfer and posting of judges—requires mandatory consultation with the Chief Justice of Pakistan and the Chief Justices of the respective high courts. The absence of such consultation, he stated, renders the President’s seniority determination “constitutionally questionable.”

Justice Shah’s legal concerns received backing from Justice Muneeb Akhtar, Senator Ali Zafar, and Barrister Gohar, indicating bipartisan support for halting the process until the seniority dispute is resolved.


Political Ramifications and Judicial Independence

The appointment of a Chief Justice in Islamabad carries significant political implications, especially considering the IHC’s growing role in adjudicating high-profile cases involving political leaders, including those from PTI, PML-N, and PPP.

Legal observers suggest that Justice Mian Gul Hassan Aurangzeb’s potential elevation could reshape the court’s direction in sensitive matters. His judgments have often reflected a balanced judicial temperament, but his promotion could be interpreted as an institutional preference amid internal discord.

This is particularly sensitive at a time when the judiciary is under public scrutiny for perceived biases and its role in Pakistan’s shifting political landscape. Some bar associations have already expressed concern over the apparent executive influence in judicial matters.


Intra-Court Appeal: The Next Crucial Step

The intra-court appeal filed by five IHC judges remains a critical stumbling block. Filed earlier this year, the appeal seeks clarity on how judicial seniority is determined, and whether the executive branch has the constitutional authority to intervene in that process.

Legal experts say the Constitutional Committee will now decide when to schedule the intra-court appeal hearing, but this may not occur until after the summer judicial recess. Courts across Pakistan have entered summer vacation, further delaying resolution.

The outcome of this appeal could have far-reaching consequences not only for Islamabad High Court but also for the overall judicial appointments process in the country.


Summary of Judicial Commission Opinions

Judicial Commission MemberOpinion on AppointmentRemarks
CJP Yahya AfridiInterim AppointmentTo maintain continuity during appeal
Justice Muneeb AkhtarOpposedSupports deferring appointment
Senator Ali Zafar (PTI)Supported InterimConditional upon pending appeal
Barrister Gohar Ali KhanSupported InterimFavors stability
Zulfiqar Abbasi (Bar Council)Supported InterimRepresented legal community
Justice Mansoor Ali ShahOpposed in writingRaised constitutional concerns

Conclusion: A Delicate Balancing Act for the Judiciary

The debate over Justice Mian Gul Hassan Aurangzeb’s appointment reflects a broader judicial crisis of confidence in Pakistan. The ongoing seniority dispute, lack of consensus within the Judicial Commission, and involvement of the executive in judicial matters are all signs of a system in flux.

Until the intra-court appeal is heard and resolved, any decision to appoint a permanent Chief Justice in Islamabad will remain fraught with controversy. In the meantime, the Judicial Commission’s indecision underscores the need for a transparent, constitutionally grounded, and depoliticized process for judicial appointments.

As Pakistan approaches a critical political and judicial phase, all eyes will remain on the IHC and the outcome of its internal legal battle—a decision that could redefine the court’s leadership and its role in the nation’s legal and political narrative.

Read more:…

Tags: commissiongovernmentinternationalNationalsocial mediatime line news
Web Desk

Web Desk

Related Posts

Imran Khan Files Intra-Court Appeal in Supreme Court Over Judges' Seniority and Transfer Case

Imran Khan Files Intra-Court Appeal in Supreme Court Over Judges’ Seniority and Transfer Case

by Web Desk
July 18, 2025
0

Introduction: PTI Founder Challenges Judges' Transfer In a significant legal development, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) founder and former Prime Minister Imran...

Senate Elections 2025: Backdoor Agreement Reached Between PTI and Opposition in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa

Senate Elections 2025: Backdoor Agreement Reached Between PTI and Opposition in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa

by Web Desk
July 18, 2025
0

Peshawar: A major political development has unfolded in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) ahead of the 2025 Senate elections. According to well-placed...

PAF CONTINGENT ARRIVES IN UK TO PARTICIPATE IN RIAT-2025

PAF CONTINGENT ARRIVES IN UK TO PARTICIPATE IN RIAT-2025

by Web Desk
July 17, 2025
0

Contingent of the Pakistan Air Force comprising state-of-the-art JF-17 Thunder Block-III fighter aircraft and the C-130 Hercules transport aircraft, has...

Government Approves Civil Awards for 71 Brave Individuals in Recognition of Heroic Acts

Government Approves Civil Awards for 71 Brave Individuals in Recognition of Heroic Acts

by Web Desk
July 17, 2025
0

In a significant move to honor and recognize acts of courage, the Government of Pakistan has approved civil awards for...

Sindh Governor Expresses Condolences to Sabri Family, Labels Kalat Tragedy an Indian Conspiracy

Sindh Governor Expresses Condolences to Sabri Family, Labels Kalat Tragedy an Indian Conspiracy

by Web Desk
July 17, 2025
0

Karachi: In a late-night visit to PIB Colony, Sindh Governor Kamran Tessori paid a solemn visit to offer condolences to...

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

Nawaz Sharif Declares Pakistan is Moving Forward Again: Emphasizes Global Attention on Kashmir

A person who came with dishonesty shook the foundations of the country, Nawaz Sharif

5 months ago
Fiery Trial in Hayatabad – A Tribute to Valor and Unity

Fiery Trial in Hayatabad – A Tribute to Valor and Unity

9 months ago

Category

  • Home
  • Top Stories
  • Latest News
  • Pakistan
  • World
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Technology
  • Health
  • Lifestyle
  • Editorial
  • Blog
  • Opinion
  • E-Paper

Social Media

Facebook Instagram Twitter LinkedIn

About us

“Time Line News” is where knowledge meets enlightenment.

With a commitment to providing accurate, fair updates, we aim to be your go-to source for information on local and global events.

  • About Us
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Contact Us

Time Line News © 2024. All Rights Reserved. Website Designed & Developed by AK Web Solutions

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Top Stories
  • Latest News
  • Pakistan
  • World
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Technology
  • Health
  • Lifestyle
  • Editorial
  • Blog
  • Opinion
  • E-Paper

Time Line News © 2024. All Rights Reserved. Website Designed & Developed by AK Web Solutions

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In